Does the Scriptural Mandate for People to Govern the Animals Mean That Christians Should Be Vegetarians?

© Photo: @johnnycapture/Unsplash

Some Christians argue that all God’s people should be vegetarians. I respect and understand their position. But I can’t agree with their conclusions, because God’s Word is clear that a different, post-paradise standard is in place for our present time on Earth. Adam and Eve and the rest of humanity before the Flood were vegetarians. But after the Flood, God explicitly told Noah, regarding animals, “I have given them to you for food, just as I have given you grain and vegetables” (Genesis 9:3).

And there’s more:

When the Lord your God expands your territory as he has promised, and you have the urge to eat meat, you may freely eat meat whenever you want. It might happen that the designated place of worship—the place the Lord your God chooses for his name to be honored—is a long way from your home. If so, you may butcher any of the cattle, sheep, or goats the Lord has given you, and you may freely eat the meat in your hometown, as I have commanded you. (Deuteronomy 12:20-21)

To say God wants all His children in the current age to be vegetarians contradicts these texts. Scripture shows that God permits humans to take the lives of animals for pragmatic uses, such as food, clothing, and labor—and also as sacrificial offerings, prior to Christ’s redemptive work on the cross, but no longer since then.

Cruelty to animals is condemned in Scripture (Genesis 49:6; Proverbs 12:10). Some argue that to eat meat or use any animal products is a form of cruelty; but since God permitted meat eating in Genesis, and confirmed that many times throughout Scripture, we know it’s not prohibited for Christ followers. (Certainly, however, we can institute more humane practices for raising and transporting animals for food that avoid mistreatment and cruelty.)

No one is commanded to eat meat, so vegetarianism and veganism are both legitimate lifestyle choices, though not biblically mandated; Jewish law had vegetarian alternatives to meat at Passover that were considered acceptable.

Some suggest that while eating meat is permitted, it is merely a concession, and that serious Christians will avoid it, almost like the Old Testament laws that permitted divorce without encouraging it (Deuteronomy 24:1-4). But Scripture contains many explicit references to animals being lawfully consumed by humans. Though eating meat didn’t happen until after the Flood—and will no longer exist on the New Earth—it’s also clear that in the present world, eating meat is acceptable, not unspiritual.

What is the point of Old Testament rules about the proper ways to slaughter an animal for food (e.g., Deuteronomy 12:21)? Certainly, these instructions encourage us to remember that taking the life of one of God’s creatures should never be done casually or taken lightly, because God is its Creator. (However, we can institute more humane practices for raising and transporting animals for food that avoid mistreatment and cruelty.)

Animals could not be eaten if they had been torn apart by other animals (Exodus 22:31; Leviticus 22:8) or died naturally (Deuteronomy 14:21). They had to be slaughtered in a way that allowed the blood to drain onto the ground (Deuteronomy 12:24).

Genesis 9:4 says, “You shall not eat flesh with its life, that is, its blood” (ESV). The Levitical law added that meat had to be boiled or roasted; it could never be eaten raw (Deuteronomy 12:21-25).

Cooking meat wasn’t just a matter of health. God wanted us to respect animals’ lives. “For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it for you on the altar to make atonement for your souls, for it is the blood that makes atonement by the life. Therefore I have said to the people of Israel, No person among you shall eat blood, neither shall any stranger who sojourns among you eat blood” (Leviticus 17:11-12, ESV).

Eating meat wasn’t limited to the Old Testament era. As Clinton Archer points out,

John the Baptist is described as surviving on a diet of locusts and wild honey (Matthew 3:4; Mark 1:6). Jesus eats fish in Luke 24:43 and presumably lamb at the Passover meal (Luke 22:15), and he feeds fish to others (Mark 6:41; John 21:9-13). And there is the matter of Peter’s vision where God instructs him to “rise, Peter, kill and eat” unclean animals (Acts 10:9-16). …The point stands that God considers killing and eating even unclean (non-kosher) animals to be permissible in the new covenant era. Paul addresses the matter of a Christian with a sensitive conscience eating meat offered to idols, with this guiding principle: “Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience. For ‘the earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof’” (1 Corinthians 10:25-26).

Greek scholar J. B. Phillips renders Romans 14:2-4 this way:

One man believes that he may eat anything, another man, without this strong conviction, is a vegetarian. The meat-eater should not despise the vegetarian, nor should the vegetarian condemn the meat-eater—they should reflect that God has accepted them both. After all, who are you to criticize the servant of somebody else, especially when that somebody else is God? It is to his own master that he gives, or fails to give, satisfactory service.

Killing animals is biblically permitted in this present world under the Curse; it is legitimate and sometimes necessary. However, to the degree that hunting animals involves subjecting them to fear, suffering, and death, it doesn’t fit with the biblical description of the New Earth, where God says “There will be no more death” (Revelation 21:4).

Randy Alcorn (@randyalcorn) is the author of over sixty books and the founder and director of Eternal Perspective Ministries. 

Topics